December 8, 2024

The six intrinsic benefits of sports, per Ted Gioia

The article is titled I Say Forbidden Things About Sports, and he does! Here are the six actual benefits:

  1. To promote physical fitness and healthy living
  2. To celebrate the values of sportsmanship and fair play—because these will make athletes better human beings, better citizens, and better participants in their communities.
  3. To teach the benefits of unselfish teamwork and counter the intense promotion of selfish individual behavior in society.
  4. To show youngsters how to deal with defeat and setbacks (as well as winning)—because they will face these again and again in life.
  5. To bond together a community—both among fans and between opponents by the goodwill created via fair competitions.
  6. To instill valuable life habits of discipline, hard work, courage, and persistence.

Instead, notes Gioia, the young athletes are taught that:

  • Winning is more important than anything.
  • There’s no value in losing. Losers get the ridicule and mockery they deserve.
  • Maybe you need to play on a team, but rewards will depend on your success and fame as an individual—so always look out for your own selfish interests.
  • Healthy living is okay, but don’t let it keep you from clubbing and late-night partying—because those are the perks of the athlete’s life.
  • Cheating will enhance all these beneifts (sic!) — just don’t get caught.

How very true. To take NBA, an American sport with which I am the most familiar, you can see it in the large swings in score when the losing team snaps and realizes they can’t win the game and therefore they don’t even try.

Do read the whole thing.

December 7, 2024

Seeing those PET scans after CAR-T 5–10 years ago was transformative but it has now become superfluous. Yes, yes, that was a nice anecdote, can I now please see some data? #ASH24

100% of patients developed grade ≥3 neutropenia. “The safety profile was mild” #ASH24

PCA maps are the new PET scan, only with zero clinical relevancy instead of at least some. Much more subjective, too! #ASH24

December 6, 2024

Quote of the day is from The Hinternet:

This, then, is the real transformation, of which Jones’s addiction diagnosis is merely a symptom: that absorption, which used to represent a secret inner life, has been sneakily transfigured into a siphon by which our native curiosity is sucked away and sold. Where once we were rapt, now we are gift-wrapped. The text is reading us.

Including this one, if you are reading it on anything other than an RSS client.

For some light weekend reading, may I suggest this Chris Arnade quartet:

The inconsistencies in capitalization are entirely Arnade’s.

United Airlines IAD→SAN flight is full, the person in front of me is talking about sickle cell disease, and I know a good chunk of people on board. I should also be looking at the #ASH24 program instead of writing this but oh well.

December 4, 2024

Big news for academic medicine yesterday:

Dr. Brian Druker, CEO of the Knight Cancer Institute at Oregon Health & Science University and developer of a drug that revolutionized cancer treatment, said he was stepping down in part because OHSU had “forgotten our mission” and is no longer a place to do cutting-edge research.

The problem with academic medicine is that it is still part of American medicine, and an MD’s worth is measured in RVUs they can generate. This is easier to calculate and cross-compare with non-academic docs, so it wins out over any other activity in an MBA’s spreadsheet.

And in even bigger news for clinical medicine:

Brian Thompson, the CEO of United Healthcare, was shot and killed by a masked man near a Midtown Manhattan hotel early Wednesday, according to police sources.

United Healthcare is, of course, the Big Bad for-profit healthcare hydra gobbling up hospitals all over the country. On an unrelated note, this seems to have been a hired hit.

Faber est suae quisque fortunae.

December 3, 2024

Quote of the week is from Adam Mastroianni:

For example, the National Institutes of Health don’t like funding anything risky, so a good way to get money from them is to show them some “promising” and “preliminary” results from a project that, secretly, you’ve already completed. When they give you a grant, you can publish the rest of the results and go “wow look it all turned out so well!” when actually you’ve been using the money to try other stuff, hopefully generating “promising” and “preliminary” results for the next grant application. Which is to say, a big part of our scientific progress depends on defrauding the government.

The article is mostly about Paul Feyerabend, author of Against Method and self-proclaimed scientific anarchist. Recommended.