First things first: The Pitt (2025) is miles better than two other era-defining medical shows, ER and House MD. The conceit — one hour per episode, one shift per season — makes for a more realistic pace. The case selection is good, if on the extreme end of any possible presentation. The medical staff personality types are spot on, They are all good, but I would like to highlight the charge nurse and the neuro-atypical first-year resident as commonly encountered phenotypes that TV shows never seem to get right.if not quite representative of the variety of English accents one would hear during rounds. And the battle between administrators and clinicians hit all the right notes, even if having the hospital’s Chief Medical Officer hover over ER staff at all hours of the day would be considered atypical for the role.
Kudos are also due for the use of prosthetics, sometimes quite grizzly, with an abundance of open wounds and mangled extremities. With so much exposed tissue I wondered why no one was wearing a mask during procedures even while, in a mid-season episode, admonishing an anti-mask patient about their beliefs. But that is, of course, another conceit, otherwise we would never be able to tell who was saying what. A more believable move was to have one of the medical students More kudos for making the two students smart, competent and lovable all at once.present for most of the cases, requiring everyone to explain what they were doing at an 8th grade level (our own 8th grader who was watching with us also appreciated this). Granted, the historical reminiscences and calling out different healthcare-related statistics were much less plausible: they reminded me of the most self-important parts of Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip that its then-arch rival 30 Rock so successfully parodied.
Admittedly, it is an unusual hospital. More than 20 ORs and so much house staff with only one attending physician during a day shift sounds… implausible. It does make for great tension-building, and it was no wonder that Noah Wiley’s character — spoiler alert — by the end of the season gets burnt out to a crisp. Another oddity is how competent and unflappable all of the staff was during — another spoiler — a major traumatic event that no one wanted to experience but everyone was prepared for. Color me skeptical that operations would have been that smooth.
Still. As fanciful as they were, ER and the less-remembered Chicago Hope were, to me at least and I suspect to many others of similar age, The less I say about House MD the better. a large part of the draw of medicine. It is good to know that there is a half-decent show out there that may keep the flame going.