Vinay Prasad asks whether health care is a human right and, using some convoluted mental gymnastics, answers no with a disturbingly LLM-like turn of phrase:
Health care, as it is practiced in 2026 America, is not a human right. It’s a tax penalty on our ignorance and wishful thinking.
This is bullshit, in the classical sense. Not to psychoanalyze Vinay [Note: The house style over here at Infinite Regress is to default to last names for any and all persons mentioned. I will on occasion make an exception for friends, which is indeed the case here. ] but this is what years of pandering to your ticket-paying audience will do to you: lose common sense.
To be pedantic, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights specifically mentions the right to health, i.e., a minimum standard of health to which everyone is entitled. The minimum standard in America is prescribed by a single law, EMTALA, which guarantees the right to emergency treatment for those who seek it. It is a floor low enough to qualify as a basement — pathetic for one of the richest nations in the world — but it is nevertheless a floor. Should the minimal standard also involve immunization and the few disease screening programs that are known to be beneficial? Yes! But they are not yet a right in the US. As I’ve noted before, I don’t think it should include the largely superfluous annual “wellness visits”. But if that’s what it takes for immunizations and screening to happen, fine.
But that’s not the bee in Vinay’s bonnet. Rather, he takes issue with the totality of American health care — who doesn’t? — and makes the case for that particular Lovecraftian horror not being a human right. Well, duh.
Cthulhuian or not, there is one good thing about the system: its extraordinarily high ceiling. This is still the place to be for getting the latest and greatest medical treatment, whether in a large academic medical center or a small community hospital, contingent on the doctors in either place knowing what they’re doing. Most stories Americans tell of their exposure to European health care are about how quickly and cheaply minor procedures are performed. Not told are stories of patients with metastatic cancer or autoimmune disease who are waitlisted for getting immunotherapy or other biologics. Or those with debilitating arthritis waiting months for a hip replacement.
With the high ceiling comes some extra girth in the middle, where there are many unnecessary treatments given and diagnostic procedures performed that Vinay rallies against. For good reason! But how you come from Ending Medical Reversal to proclaiming that health care is not a human right is beyond my comprehension.