The Reverse Turing Test
To elaborate on the chatbot: it isn’t that it upgraded my view of how good artificial intelligence can be, but rather that it downgraded my view of human intelligence. ChatGPT is very good at stringing out empty phrases and filler words — in other words, at producing bullshit in the Harry Frankfurt sense. Its skill in writing plausibly-looking college essays, personal statements, and letters of recommendation reminded me, maybe even showed me for the first time, that most of those are bullshit too.
As someone who has spent the better part of the last 12 years drafting his own letters of recommendation, Thank you, USCIS! it was demoralizing to be reminded to all that wasted effort. Worse yet was the stream of college professors lamenting the new reality of now and forever compromised term papers, decorated with screenshots of ChatGPT’s essays, blind to their own self-condemnation: if an unintelligent, unreasoning, letter-guessing algorithm can produce content to your liking better than your own students, then what kind of a class are you teaching there, Professor?
Instead of hearlding the rise of artificial general intelligence, ChatGPT showed me deficiencies of human intelligence by being a variant of the reverse Turing test: can a human write sufficiently well to be recognized as one? This is, of course, not my original thought but rather Taleb’s, who wrote about the reverse Turing test two decades ago in Fooled by Randomness, and mentioned it again in light of the ChatGPT screenshot onslaught. So am I failing the test too?
I consider myself a fairly rational creature, and yet…
- Mastodon out of the box: An eye sore! Unusable! What is this, Discord? Because I hate Discord!
- Mastodon with Light theme and advanced web interface on: Where have you been all my life?
There is a good overview of the two ways Micro.blog can interact with Mastodon, from @pmcconnell. I much prefer the full integration (Option 2 in the text), but it looks like only Option 1 completely matches the formatting. Is that a bug or a technical limitation?
So it looks like the new Pokemon game is buggy as hell. This brings back fond memories of TES II: Daggerfall which way nearly unplayable when it first came out but after a half-dozen or so patches became my favorite game of all time.
It is remarkable how quickly the new Verge homepage became my go-to for tech information. Nilay Patel’s introductory article from two months ago was prescient.
Eleven years have passed since the 11/11/11 release of Skyrim. Tempus fugit.
And the day is off to a great start!
I have heard nothing but good things about the Playdate, save for the screen not being viewable under direct sunlight. Good thing it will be a wet, cold October in DC.
Orange tabby cat wearing a crown: Stable Diffusion running on a meager M1 versus Midjourney running on who knows what. Either way, the visual arts will never be the same.


Goodbye, Drummer (for now)
Drummer is an online outliner that enables quick, easy, and near real-time posting of text both long form and short — what we used to call blogs back in the good old days of two years ago. Dave Winer created it for his own purposes, but it works beautifuly with just your Twitter account as a login. Here is my page.
As things are still very much in progress, Dave recommended doing daily backups. Sadly, I didn’t, and as of today’s updates a few weeks' worth of half-baked notes are wiped out from the Drummer server (but thankfully not from the website they helped create). That’ll teach me.
Since posting to that page is on hold until everything is back in order, expect more — dare I say daily — updates here. Managing markdown files is not nearly as intutitive or pleasant to use as Dave’s outliner, but he seemes to be working on an OPML to markdown converter. That will be well worth the wait.
Blogroll
I, for one, am glad that blogs are making a comeback. Here are a few I’ve been reading for at least a few months, many of them for years, some for decades.
Applied philosophers
The only true philosophers of our time.
- Mathflaneur (by Nassim Taleb)
- Ribbonfarm (by Venkatesh Rao, who also has a newsletter of half-baked ideas he calls Ribbonfarm Studio)
The new scientists
People without major academic credentials who have interesting ideas about science.
- Alexey Guzey (also see Guzey’s Best of Twitter, and also see New Science)
- Applied Divinity Studies
- Astral Codex Ten (former Slate Star Codex)
- Fantastic Anachronism
- Gwern
- Nintil
The old scientists
People with major academic credentials and interesting ideas, something to teach, or both.
- I am Intramural (from the NIH Intramural Research Program)
- Statistical Modeling, Causal Inference, and Social Science by Andew Gelman
- Statistical Thinking by Frank Harrell
- Stephen Wolfram Writings
- The Mathematical Oncology Blog (see also This week in Mathematical Oncology)
The ludites
People against modernity of one sort or another.
- Axiom of Chance (Simon DeDeo, who does not seem to have a Twitter account)
- Patrick Rhone (who does have a Twitter account)
- Study Hacks (by Cal Newport, whose Twitter account, if real, has been abandoned years ago)
- Wrath of Gnon (who is in fact — and sadly — all Twitter)
People doing their own thing
Unclassifiable but exhilarating.
- Craig Mod (and on Twitter) who walks, makes books, and takes photos.
- Garden of Forking Paths (by Abe Callard, who watches movies)
- Rands in Repose (by Michael Lopp, who manages people)
- The Sephist (by Linus, who makes his own software tools)
- Thought Asylum (by Stephen Millard, who makes other people’s software tools more usable)
Apple enthusiasts
Some tips, a few tricks, many opinions.
- And now it’s all this
- Brett Terpstra (if you have a Mac and use it for more than just browsing the internet and answering email — not that there is anything wrong with that — Terpstra’s tools will save you days of work; he could easily have been slotted in the category above, but the Apple tag predates all and he is an Apple lifer)
- Daring Fireball (by John Gruber)
- Hypercritical (a sadly neglected blog by John Siracusa although what you should really check out is the podcast of the same name which has been out of production for years but still fun and relevant)
- Macdrifter
- Marco.org (by Marco Arment)
Finance-adjacent
Economists and investors, for the most part.
- Global Inequality (by Branko Milanović)
- Marginal Revolution (by Tyler Cowen and Alex Tabarrok who also wrote an excellent textbook in economics which I plan on reading some day, likely in retirement)
- Pseudoerasmus (the last post was in 2017 so I’m not holding out any hope, though he is on Twitter)
- The Rational Walk (see also Rational Reflections and the Twitter account)
- 10-K diver (as close to a blog that a Twitter account can get)
Journalist-cum-substackers
Former or current journalists who now earn some or all of their living by writing newsletters via Substack, which is slowly reinventing blogs (in the sense of reinventing the wheel, not actually making them better and in fact in many was making them much worse).
- Everything Studies (by John Nerst)
- Galaxy Brain (by Charlie Warzel)
- Insight (by Zeynep Tufekci, who is hands down the best journalist currently writing)
- Slow Boring (by Matthew Yglesias)
Company blogs
For when I really want to know when the next update is coming.
- Devonian Times, from the makers of my note-collecting tool of choice, DEVONthink
- The Omni Group, makers of OmniFocus (and OmniGraffle, which I don’t use often enough for it to be essential but which is fairly
- Wolfram Blog, from the makers of Mathematica