Published on
[Permalink] Reading time: 2 minutes Posted in: rss
Three links for Monday, and I am in a disagreeable mood
Cal Newport: Forget Chatbots. You Need a Notebook. Yes, Cal, if you are a maths professor working on a proof. I love putting my fountain pen to paper as much as anyone but they are not sufficient for any of the hats I wear.
Eric Topol: Multilingualism and Extending Healthspan. Another thing I should nominally be for as it is positive reinforcement of my own (two languages) and my children’s education (3+ and counting), but no matter how many potential confounders these researchers adjusted for I am absolutely convinced that there are residual confounders behind these results. Learn languages for their own sake, not to “prolong healthspan” or to — what this study actually checks for — make some proteins in your blood go one way instead of another.
Ezekiel Emanuel at al for the NYT: Make Medical School Three Years. Here is a statement I could get behind provided there is adequate rationale — that undergrad premed is sufficient for basic science knowledge, that it is essential to attain practical skills during postgraduate education as early as possible, that the fourth year of medical school is pure formality of one low-stakes elective after another since most students will have already matched. But no, the rationale here is financial, and that is purely idiotic. The high tuition is taken as a given and all steps stem from there. The authors should check their premises.